Watch This The Office Fan Theory and You'll Never See the Show the Same Way Again

Michael Scott was right: You can't trust Toby. 🙅 Here's why.

NBC

Toby Flenderson, the HR representative for Dunder Mifflin's Scranton branch on The Office, is a pretty tragic character. His wife left him. His love for Pam goes unrequited. And, of course, Michael Scott flat out hates him.

But as it turns out, Michael may have a good reason not to like Toby. Eagle-eyed fans of the former NBC series have found a ton of evidence that points to Toby being the infamous Scranton Strangler, a mass murderer who strikes while Pam gives birth to Jim's baby.

It's a pretty wild theory. But it's scary AF how much it all makes sense. ☠️

Watch this and then decide for yourself: Is Toby the Scranton Strangler?

HOT RIGHT NOW

This Kylie Jenner Conspiracy Theory Is Bonkers

This Kylie Jenner Conspiracy Theory Is Bonkers

LOL

Could Top Gun Be a Gay Love Story? This Theory Says Yes

Could Top Gun Be a Gay Love Story? This Theory...

Wingman ✈️

This Justin Bieber Conspiracy Theory Is Beyond Weird

This Justin Bieber Conspiracy Theory Is Beyond...

WHOA!

This Insane Riverdale Fan Theory May Have Just Revealed a New Murderer

This Insane Riverdale Fan Theory May Have Just...

OH NO, BETTY

This Game of Thrones Theory Will Convince You That Bran Stark Is the Night King

This Game of Thrones Theory Will Convince You...

King Stark?

HOT RIGHT NOW

This Kylie Jenner Conspiracy Theory Is Bonkers

This Kylie Jenner Conspiracy Theory Is Bonkers

LOL

Could Top Gun Be a Gay Love Story? This Theory Says Yes

Could Top Gun Be a Gay Love Story? This Theory...

Wingman ✈️

This Justin Bieber Conspiracy Theory Is Beyond Weird

This Justin Bieber Conspiracy Theory Is Beyond...

WHOA!